NYT's Correspondent Mark Landler's Shrill Coverage of GermanyPosted by Joerg Wolf in German Politics on Friday, July 13. 2007
The New York Times' Germany correspondent Mark Landler often exaggerates and is sometimes just wrong. The latest example is his July 11 article "Debate on Terror Threat Stirs Germany," which starts with
While the British public reacted to the latest terrorist strike there with stoicism and a practiced determination to get on with their lives, Germany has erupted in a rancorous dispute over how to deal with a terrorist threat that has yet to materialize here.I take issue with these claims: First of all, is Landler saying that Germans are not "getting on with their lives"? He certainly gives that impression with the comparison with Britain. Hey, this fear mongering did not happen in Germany: "Americans have apparently heeded the U.S. government's advice to prepare for terror attacks, emptying hardware store shelves of duct tape," reported CNN in February 2003. Second, the German debate about the government's counter-terrorism plans has not "erupted" after the failed terrorist strikes in Britain, but has been going on since September 11, 2001. Every Interior Secretary has been accused of overreacting and violating civil liberties. There is a healthy debate going on about the right measures. What's wrong with that? Such debates took place in Britain as well in the past. Third, a terrorist threat has "materialized" in Germany many years ago; definitely since the deployment of the Bundeswehr to Afghanistan in early 2002. In the past, many American observers, like Instapundit and Anne Applebaum claimed that Europe is denial about terrorism. Last year Pursuit of Serenity has criticized the exaggerated article by Mark Landler "Bomb Plot Shocks Germans Into Antiterrorism Debate." Landler has also exaggerated today's impact of unexploded World War II bombs in his article "60 Years Later, Buried Bombs Still Frighten Germans, and Kill Some." Marian Wirth, the author of Pursuit of Serenity, has criticized this article in his blog post The Germans, the War - and Bombs and added: It's not for the first time, that I got the impression that Mr. Landler is exaggerating things and is actually drawing a picture of Germany which strucks me as... inaccurate.Why is the New York Times coverage of Germany so shrill and portraits Germans as being "shocked" and "frightened"? Are they trying to compete with the New York Post? Related posts in the Atlantic Review: • Still Deadly: World War II Bombs, Modern Cluster Bombs, Landmines and Small Arms • How Good or Bad is the US Media Coverage of Germany? The Suspected Pakistan-Germany Terror ConnectionPosted by Joerg Wolf in German Politics on Wednesday, July 11. 2007
"Indications that terrorists may be planning attacks on Europe are growing following a slew of arrests of Islamists in Pakistan," writes Spiegel International:
In June, for the first time since the Sept. 11, 2001 terrorist attacks, the German Chancellery (Angela Merkel's equivalent of the White House) even summoned the so-called Security Group, a government round that meets only in periods of crisis, and which was this time attended by the state secretaries of the Interior, Foreign and Defense Ministries.Pakistan is going to extradite a German terror suspect, but then there is another suspect: As for Hussain al-M., President Pervez Musharraf's diplomats have signaled that the German government could choose whether it wants him or not. The case of the stateless Lebanese man al-M., who holds a permanent residence permit in Neunkirchen, in Germany's Saarland region, is considered especially delicate in Berlin. Government officials still remember all too well another Pakistani detainee for whom Berlin took no responsibility (more...) -- that of German-born Turkish citizen Murat Kurnaz. Kurnaz ended up at Guantanamo.Related posts in the Atlantic Review: • The Guantanamo detainee from Germany • Twists and Turns in the Murat Kurnaz Affair Vigilant, But Not AfraidPosted by Joerg Wolf in on Sunday, July 1. 2007
After three failed terror attacks in London and Glasgow, the Brits continue with the big public events this weekend, like the Gay Pride Parade, Wimbledon and the concert for Diana. The German paper Tagesspiegel praises the "stiff upper lip." The Nosemonkey in London has the right attitude and writes "Terrorists these days are rubbish."
Would Germans and Americans be as cool and continue with business as usual? Shortly after the London attacks of 7/7/2005, the We're not Afraid campaign started. Remember the funny pictures demonstrating fearlessness in solidarity with Britain and in defiance of the global terror movements? A good reminder from the "We're not Afraid" About us page:We refuse to respond to aggression and hatred in kind. Instead, we who are not afraid will continue to live our lives the best way we know how. We will work, we will play, we will laugh, we will live. We will not waste one moment, norRelated posts in the Atlantic Review: • Responding to "Al-Qaeda's Revival" • The State of Emergency Infrastructure • Increased Terror Threat: Germans in Pakistani Terror Camps Will Merkel Request the Extradition of CIA Agents?Posted by Joerg Wolf in Transatlantic Relations on Tuesday, June 26. 2007
Spiegel:
Officials in Washington have since realized that the German investigation is more than just a symbolic act. This week in Berlin, a group of senior officials from the interior, foreign and justice ministries will meet to discuss the sensitive issue of how the German government should handle the Munich petition for "arrest for the purposes of extradition." There is general agreement within the government in Berlin that the request should be promptly delivered to the Bush administration, which would be tantamount to an official request for the arrest of the men being sought. (...)Apparently, the German prosecutors discovered the real names of the CIA pilots involved in the "renditions": The US agents were not as smart as the police had assumed -- or perhaps criminally negligent. Thanks to the US Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), all it took was a simple computer search for the investigators in Old Europe, without any official assistance from the US Department of Justice, to determine the real names of "Captain James Fairing," "Eric Fain" and "Kirk James Bird."UNRELATED: "Verboten: Germany Bans Tom Cruise" reports ABC News: Germany has barred the makers of a movie about a plot to kill Adolf Hitler from filming at German military sites because its star Tom Cruise is a Scientologist, the Defence Ministry said on Monday. Putting the Death Toll in PerspectivePosted by Joerg Wolf in US Foreign Policy on Monday, June 25. 2007
Prose Before Hos looks at civilian death statistics:
Every 9.62 days, there is an equivalent amount of casualties in Iraq & Afghanistan as September 11th. (...) In 11 days as many Iraqi & Afghani civilians are killed as the entire amount of American military personnel killed since the invasion of Afghanistan in 2002 and the invasion of Iraq in 2003.I guess, the message is: Given the huge influence 9/11 had on the American psyche, it is hard to underestimate the impact of war on the Iraqis. Likewise, I have read somewhere: Although many more Turks died in PKK attacks than Americans died on 9/11, Turkey has not invaded Northern Iraq yet, but the pressure is increasing and the United States is trying hard to prevent an invasion. If people are attacked, esp. if they lose family members, then there is an (irrational) urge to hit back. • Different topic, but also about statistics and demographics: Reader ArnoNymus recommends the Economist article "Suddenly, the old world looks younger: Reports of Europe's death are somewhat exaggerated" as a contrast to Mark Steyn Increased Terror Threat: Germans in Pakistani Terror CampsPosted by Editors in German Politics on Sunday, June 24. 2007
ABC News:
German authorities called for increased vigilance on Friday against possible terror attacks, saying the kind of threat detected before the September 11, 2001, attacks on the United States had resurfaced. Interior Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble said the threat was "serious" and that suicide attacks were possible on German soil. (...)Related posts: U.S. Citizen Indicted for Training Al Qaeda Operatives in Germany and US and German Officials Issue Terror Threat Warnings US was better prepared to interrogate Germans in WWII than todays terror suspectsPosted by Joerg Wolf in US Foreign Policy on Wednesday, June 6. 2007
New York Times:
A group of experts advising the intelligence agencies are arguing that the harsh techniques used since the 2001 terrorist attacks are outmoded, amateurish and unreliable. The psychologists and other specialists, commissioned by the Intelligence Science Board, make the case that more than five years after the Sept. 11 attacks, the Bush administration has yet to create an elite corps of interrogators trained to glean secrets from terrorism suspects. While billions are spent each year to upgrade satellites and other high-tech spy machinery, the experts say, interrogation methods — possibly the most important source of information on groups like Al Qaeda — are a hodgepodge that date from the 1950s, or are modeled on old Soviet practices. (...)The Defense Intelligence Agency offers the full report (pdf). Via: The Daily Dish and Balkinization It would help if more people would watch the well-made, balanced, multi-faceted, and suspenseful TV series "Sleeper Cell" on DVD (Amazon.com, Amazon.de) rather than "24". Anybody a fan? More Terrorism to Expect due to "Lost Honor" of Iraqi Sunnis?Posted by Joerg Wolf in US Foreign Policy on Saturday, June 2. 2007
"Desperate Iraqi Refugees Turn to Sex Trade in Syria" writes the New York Times:
“During the war we lost everything,” she said. “We even lost our honor.” She insisted on being identified by only part of her name — Umm Hiba means mother of Hiba. For anyone living in Damascus these days, the fact that some Iraqi refugees are selling sex or working in sex clubs is difficult to ignore. (...) Many of these women and girls, including some barely in their teens, are recent refugees. Some are tricked or forced into prostitution, but most say they have no other means of supporting their families. As a group they represent one of the most visible symptoms of an Iraqi refugee crisis that has exploded in Syria in recent months.Personal Comment: How many Iraqis have turned or will turn to terrorism to take revenge for this "lost honor" of their people? Perhaps a new generation of disgruntled America-hating Iraqi Sunnis will grow up in the next decade. The perfect fodder for terrorist groups. The feeling of "lost honor" and the perception of humiliation in general are the number one motivation for terrorists. Harvard's Jessica Stern for instance writes: For the last six years I have interviewed terrorists, trying to discover what makes people join a holy-war organization and what makes them stay. Although the terrorists have described a variety of individual grievances, there was one common thread: their overwhelming feelings of humiliation.Of course, talking about terrorists' perceived humiliation does not mean that their hatred is justified. I am just saying that we need to be concerned about Iraqi Sunnis. For our own self-interest! This is not about having empathy with Saddam's clans. Not all Iraqi Sunnis were privileged. My point is: We don't want Iraqi Sunnis to grow up hating the West and perpetrate terrorist attacks in the US and Europe in the next ten to twenty years. Therefore, we should help them so that they don't feel humiliated because their relatives have to prostitute themselves in Syria. I assume the US is not helping Syria to deal with this refugee crisis because of Syria's support for Hezbollah etc, right? Perhaps the US should help Syria. The United Nations could do more as well, but its agencies do not get much funding and are busy with even worse refugee crises in Africa and Asia. Europe should help Syria and Jordan as well. Some experts believe that Jordan might collapse due to the huge number of Iraqi refugees in addition to the many Palestinian refugees. What do you think? Tom Tancredo in Republican Debate on Torture: "I'm looking for Jack Bauer"Posted by Joerg Wolf in US Domestic and Cultural Issues on Tuesday, May 22. 2007
Please let me generalize a lot in answering these questions:
Why are European leftists unpopular in the US? Because they talk so much about social justice, the welfare state and evil capitalists etc. Why are American conservatives unpopular in Europe? Because they talk so much about family values, religion, gay marriage, abortion, torture etc. None of these issues is central to America's political problems and can be fixed by politicians. When American conservatives read about European debates they can constantly shake their head in amazement about the strange ways in the old world. Europeans (and liberal Americans) shake their head in amazement, when they read the Los Angeles Times article about the second Republican presidential debate: "The GOP's torture enthusiasts": IT WASN'T AN edifying spectacle: a group of middle-aged white guys competing with one another to see who could do the best impersonation of Jack Bauer, torture enthusiast and the central character on Fox's hit show "24." In Tuesday's Republican presidential primary debate, Fox News moderator Brit Hume — who appears to have been watching too much "24" himself — raised what he described as "a fictional but we think plausible scenario involving terrorism and the response to it." He then laid out the kind of "ticking-bomb" scenario on which virtually every episode of "24" is premised — precisely the kind that most intelligence experts consider fictional and entirely implausible.Mitt Romney suggested: "My view is, we ought to double Guantanamo" and "enhanced interrogation techniques have to be used." And Colorado Rep. Tom Tancredo said: "We're wondering about whether water-boarding would be a — a bad thing to do? I'm looking for Jack Bauer at that time, let me tell you." This remark was according to the LA Times "greeted by uproarious laughter and applause from the audience because, after all, who doesn't enjoy thinking about a hunky guy threatening to gouge out a detainee's eye with a hunting knife?" (Jack Bauer is supposed to be "hunky"?). Politicians appear stupid, when they look for help from TV show characters. Dialog International shows excerpts of the FOX News video. And below is Stephen Colbert's take on the second Republican presidential debate; might take some time to load: Conservative Americans, who blame Anti-Americanism for Europeans' harsh criticism of Republicans, might want to have a word with their own politicians and their eager bases and/or listen to McCain's honorable statement in the presidential debate. Though, I don't want to praise Saint McCain too much since he was joking about bombing Iran a few weeks ago. According to CNN, McCain answered a question about military action against Iran with the chorus of the surf-rocker classic "Barbara Ann." "That old, eh, that old Beach Boys song, Bomb Iran," he said. "Bomb, bomb, bomb, bomb, anyway, ah ..." His audience laughed.FOX News and some presidential candidates give US conservatism a bad name. Please, don't just blame your lack of popularity on European Anti-Americanism. If you want to be liked by Europeans, please elect serious politicians, who do not refer to Jack Bauer and sing Beach Boys songs, when they are asked serious questions about matters of life and death. They are reinforcing the worst stereotypes Europeans have about Americans. And I am saying this as a fan of both "24" and the Beach Boys. US and German Officials Issue Terror Threat WarningsPosted by Joerg Wolf in German Politics, US Foreign Policy on Saturday, May 12. 2007
ABC NEWS (HT: David):
U.S. and German officials fear terrorists are in the advanced planning stages of an attack on U.S. military personnel or tourists in Germany. "The information behind the threat is very real," a senior U.S. official told ABC News.Reuters: A threat warning issued by United States in Germany last month could involve attack plans by an al Qaeda-affiliated group of Kurdish extremists, officials said on Friday. U.S. and German authorities said, however, that there was no new threat in Germany beyond the official April 20 State Department warning. They were responding to a report by ABC News on its Web site on Friday that officials believed terrorists were in the advanced planning stages for an attack on U.S. military personnel or tourists in Germany. In the April 20 warning, the U.S. embassy in Germany encouraged Americans in the country to increase their vigilance and take appropriate steps to bolster their personal security.Guardian: Hundreds of German police combed offices and flats associated with leftwing activists across six northern cities yesterday, saying they had evidence that a terrorist organisation was planning to disrupt next month's G8 summit. Congressman Expresses his Wish that Terrorists Kill Families of EU ParliamentariansPosted by Joerg Wolf in Transatlantic Relations on Thursday, April 26. 2007
The Voice of America reports about a US Congress hearing, in which members of the European Parliament have defended the findings of a report criticizing the practice of extraordinary rendition.
Dialog International has the C-Span video of the frank debate. At the end of the video clip, US Congressman Dana Rohrabacher angrily retorts: Well, I hope it's your families, I hope it's your families that suffer the consequences [of a terrorist attack].Personal Comment: If Representative Rohrabacher were a European, thousands of US newspapers and blogs would complain about wild Anti-Americanism in Europe and Schadenfreude etc. The German press and blogs, however, just ignore Rohrabacher. CORRECTION: It seems that Rohrabacher did not address the members of the EU parliament, but some American citizens in the audiences, as our reader Fuchur pointed out. Thank you for the correction and informative comments. Though, it should be pointed out that Rohrabacher and the EU parliamentarians were engaged in a lively debate on a controversial issue, as the video and the VOA article demonstrate. Fulbrighter Killed at Virginia TechPosted by Joerg Wolf in Fulbright, Transatlantic Relations on Wednesday, April 18. 2007
The shooting on the Virginia Tech Campus started in the Introductory German class. The first victim was Professor Jamie Bishop, 35, who was a US Fulbright scholar to Christian-Albrechts University at Kiel, Germany. More information at Dialog International.
Our condolences to the families of all the victims of this tragedy. UPDATE: Uwe Koch, president of the German Fulbright Association, has sent the following Letter of Condolence to Virginia Tech and to the international mailing list for Fulbright Associations as well as posted it on the Memorial Site: Dear Dr. Steger:
« previous page
(Page 3 of 7, totaling 84 entries)
next page »
|
SponsorTips From Our Readers
The above links on transatlantic issues have been recommended by trusted readers. More information about this web 2.0 project ;-)
BlogrollGoogle the SiteSUPPORT THIS SITEHot TopicsClick on one of the following links to see all Atlantic Review posts about this topic in a chronological order with the latest post on top:
Afghanistan Anti-Americanism Economics Iran Iraq Merkel Polls Terrorism Click here for the full list of all topics. Read posts from specific Atlantic Review authors |
Home - About Us - Newsletter - Transatlantic Relations - US Foreign Policy - Various RSS Feeds Designed for Atlantic Review by Carl.

Latest Comments
General James L. Jones was everywhere: Vietnam, Near East, Iraq, Afghanistan. Very [...]
David about Obama the Atlanticist?
The appointment of Susan Rice as UN ambassador is also significant. Obama has [...]
David about Obama's Wish List for Europe
The northeast is covered with Lukoil filling stations. I try to avoid them since I'm [...]
nanne about Obama's Wish List for Europe
Don, you might want to re-read [...]
Pat Patterson about Obama's Wish List for Europe
Caviar ? We'll boycott caviar and all those skinny Russian models! That'll fix their [...]
Pamela about Obama's Wish List for Europe
Boycot Russian goods? WHAT Russian goods? The only product I've ever seen from [...]