Favorable Views of the U.S. Drop Again in GermanyPosted by Joerg Wolf in Transatlantic Relations on Sunday, July 1. 2007 Pew Global Attitudes Project:Russia and its president also are unpopular in many countries of the world. But criticisms of that nation and its leader are sharpest in Western Europe where many citizens worry about overdependence on the Russian energy supply. For instance, despite sharp declines in favorable views of the U.S. in France and Germany since 2002, Russia's image in those countries is no better. (...) Medienkritik on How to Improve US Public DiplomacyPosted by Joerg Wolf in Transatlantic Relations on Sunday, June 17. 2007
Eric Staal of Republicans Abroad Germany was a guest of the public TV talk show "Maybrit Illner" and has effectively responded to criticism against the United States and received applause from the studio audience.
Eric said that he respects the criticism, but pointed out that criticism of US policy should have an honest motivation (like concern for injustices in the world) rather than be motivated by another political agenda. He doubts whether many critics have such an honest motivation, because people don't protest against China because of Darfur, for instance. Ray D. of Davids Medienkritik describes Eric's talk show appearance as a stellar example of how Americans should engage the German media and complains: The US Embassy in Berlin is a near total failure in its efforts to engage the German mass media so as to reach the largest possible German audience. The American taxpayer is being under-served by his or her representatives in Germany. Frankly - the public diplomacy officials at the US Embassy in Berlin ought to send Eric Staal half of their annual paychecks - because he just did more to engage the German people in 2 minutes than they have done in the past year.UPDATE: Is it the job of ambassadors to appear on TV? The German ambassador certainly does it often, as Pat points out in the comments section. Besides, here is an example from August 2002, when the transatlantic disagreements over Iraq intensified: Germany's Ambassador Ischinger went on the fiercely pro-war FOX News and told the rather aggressive host Bill O'Reilly why Germany is not supporting the war plans: We have our hands full with the fight against al Qaeda and the Taliban. Why do we have to go against Iraq right now? Are you really sure that containment has failed?Ischinger also wrote on the embassy homepage in August 2002: "An Attack on Iraq Now Could Harm International Coalition Against Terrorism." Ischinger defended Germany again on The O'Reilly Factor in December 2003 as Sonja wrote in the Atlantic Review post Pressure on Germany by FOX’s O’Reilly Factor (in German). In May 2006, Ischinger also wrote a pretty outspoken and US critical editorial in the Washington Post. See the Atlantic Review post: Germany's Outgoing Ambassador to the U.S. discusses the War on Terrorism Albania: The Most Pro-American Country in the World?Posted by Editors in on Sunday, June 10. 2007
New York Times:
“Albania is for sure the most pro-American country in Europe, maybe even in the world,” said Edi Rama, Tirana’s mayor and leader of the opposition Socialists. “Nowhere else can you find such respect and hospitality for the president of the United States. Even in Michigan, he wouldn’t be as welcome.” Transatlantic ObsessionsPosted by Joerg Wolf in Transatlantic Relations on Thursday, May 31. 2007
Europeans and Americans should mind their own business. That's the main thesis of watchblogs for Anti-Americanism and French-bashing.
Blogs like Davids Medienkritik complain that the German media is obsessed with America's real and imagined wrongdoings, while blogs like SuperFrenchie complain about the American media's obsession with France's domestic politics. So, I guess, it is time to acknowledge that both Europeans and Americans have their obsessions about their distant relatives on the other side of the Atlantic. Prejudices and unfair reporting is not unique to one side, as some people sometimes seem to claim. It is not rocket science to come to this conclusion, but I guess it serves as a good reminder. Still, it remains weird and unfortunate that the German media is soo obsessed with the United States and that the US media is soo obsessed with France. Both country's media outlets would do good to reduce the obsessions on some silly topics and cover more important issues like poverty in our own countries and around the world, wars and conflicts in Africa, how to increase energy efficiency etc. Two relevant quotes from the watchblogs: Flocon asks in SuperFrenchie: "Will you please mind your own business?" The recent presidential elections in France have been a renewed opportunity for most of the American MSM to display a permanent feature that is to be found in many articles reporting on our country: an obsession which translates into an incessant set of criticisms about how France is run, particularly its economy. Above all, the 35-hour workweek, the 5-week paid vacation and the free and high-quality healthcare and educational systems seem to be particularly unbearable to those many journalists, columnists and reporters who also seem to have trouble understanding why the labor market is regulated, why workers are entitled to social rights and protections, and even sometimes are allowed to go on strike.Likewise, Ray D. has listed some "Pet issues common in German media coverage of the United States" in Davids Medienkritik: # Perceived American religiosity.I do not fully understand the irrational obsessions with the US and France. I sort of know why it is popular, but I do not fully understand the feelings. Besides, I also do not fully understand why soo many Americans and French are interested in reading about the latest Anti-American headline or the latest French-bashing comment every single day. No, I am not envious of the huge readership of Medienkritik and SuperFrenchie, but I simply fail to fully understand the huge interest into such single topics. Anti-Americanism and French bashing are pretty boring to me: The same magazines and the same politicians make the same stupid statements. Why do I want to read about (more or less) the same stuff every single day? Four Myths About Transatlantic RelationsPosted by Joerg Wolf in Transatlantic Relations on Wednesday, May 16. 2007
William Drozdiak, president of the American Council on Germany and the former chief European correspondent for The Washington Post, wrote an op-ed about transatlantic relations. (Hat tip: Don) Unfortunately, the Washington Post editors chose an headline "4 Myths About America-Bashing in Europe," although only two of the four myths could be put into the category America-Bashing. The headline choice indicates that they find the term "America-Bashing" more profitable than the term "transatlantic relations." So it is not just the European media, which focuses on the negative aspects on the other side of the Atlantic.
Excerpts from Drozdiak's op-ed: Opinion polls cite widespread dismay with the Iraq war, our dog-eat-dog social model and the arrogance of an imperial superpower that places itself above international law. But behind the surveys about "why they hate us" lies a reservoir of goodwill waiting to be tapped among foreigners who would prefer to see the United States succeed rather than fail. This love-hate melange has perpetuated four modern myths about transatlantic relations that deserve to be debunked. German Intellectuals "flawed reasoning" behind the Support of the Iraq WarPosted by Joerg Wolf in German Politics, US Foreign Policy on Wednesday, May 9. 2007
Gustav Seibt wrote about German intellectuals who supported the Iraq war. Sign and Sight provides a translation of his Sueddeutsche Zeitung article from February 2007:
The motivations behind the powerful intellectual support of the war should be analysed in retrospect, and not only because the hopes that were invested in the Iraq War were so disastrously disappointed. We should be concerned, for one, with monitoring the success rate of our prognoses but more importantly, with exploring the argumentative basis of our war confidence in the West. Only then will the "war of ideas" between the Western public and the Islamic world that the essayist Paul Berman been demanding since 2001, seriously begin.Andrew Hammel makes an observation concerning Seibt's article in German Joys, which I believe is true for many debates: I noticed the same pattern as Seibt did. I think part of the explanation is that the hawkish intellectuals who supported the war engaged not with the serious critiques from war opponents, but with the goofy arguments of the weird left. They then built their case for war on a refutation of those silly arguments, rather than a carefully-reasoned argument why the war itself was necessary or desirable. "Because the anti-American, anti-Semitic wacko left is strongly against this war, and because I despise those people, the war must be a good idea. How can those people, whom I've spent my life criticizing, be right about anything?" America Has Become "Politically Radioactive" (Update)Posted by Sonja Bonin in Transatlantic Relations on Tuesday, May 1. 2007
“Some sort of gripes of the globe, fluctuating in strength, manifest themselves in the critique of the United States,” says Jan Roß in the esteemed German weekly newspaper DIE ZEIT. “This anti-Americanism forms a new global ideology, the mainstream culture (“Leitkultur”) for all protest against the current state of affairs, like the different shades of socialism used to be over the last decades.”
This dominating undertone against the United States, claims Roß, transcends all tangible controversial issues at hand. It’s proved long-lasting and not confined to traditional foes or the losers of globalization. In fact, according to a BBC poll, dramatically fewer people, from the Philippines to India to Germany to South Korea, believe in a “mostly positive” influence of the US any longer. A divided attitude towards America “drives Europe and the Atlantic alliance apart; for most governments, everything American has become “politically radioactive”: Touch it, and you’re inevitably contaminated in the eyes of the voters at the next election. Outside the transatlantic community, the idea takes root that the EU’s main raison d’être should be to “put the arrogant United States in place”. Asia doesn’t participate in the “global psycho-game with Americans in need to feel loved on the one hand and bitter Europeans or Arabs on the other hand; it just profits from it.” UPDATE: Richard has translated one of the key paragraphs of the Zeit article "Anti-Americanism: The Global Bellyache." Thank you! A kind of global bellyache in varying intensity is showing up in criticisms of the United States. Anti-Americanism is a new global ideology, the predominate culture of protest against prevailing relations, just as it was over decades for the various incarnations of Socialism (...)UPPERDATE: Ray D. has translated the entire article for Davids Medienkritik. Anti-EuropeanismPosted by Joerg Wolf in Transatlantic Relations on Tuesday, May 1. 2007
The Economist's Lexington writes about Anti-Europeanism in the United States, which is an interesting topic. Unfortunately he does not add much to the debate, but covers the same "Eurabia" examples that have been criticized many times before: America's anti-Europeans believe that "Europe is committing demographic and economic suicide" because of the birthrate and economic regulations. Besides, Europe is seen as "a post-Christian society" and "Muslims are filling Europe's demographic and spiritual void." Yawn.
Lexington concludes: "Curing global anti-Americanism primarily means repairing America's relations with the rest of the world; but it also means uprooting the anti-European weeds that have flourished in America in the past few years." Recommended by our ReadersPosted by Joerg Wolf in Transatlantic Relations on Sunday, April 15. 2007
The Atlantic Review's sidebar feature "Tips from our Readers" is a great success. There are constantly plenty of interesting articles:
• Don recommended the Guardian's "Hamburgers or foie gras," which argues: "Don't exaggerate the extent of anti-American feeling. The US should identify its real enemies." • David recommended two very different articles in the New York Times: German Army Recruit Given Racist Orders in Training as well as Germany’s Export-Led Economy Finds Global Niche: Germany’s transformation from Europe’s sick man to its most stalwart performer is by now well entrenched. So sanguine are German executives about their future that many brush aside fears that a slowdown in the United States could knock their export-led recovery off track.• David also found this article in Politico: German Ambassador Attends Obama Fundraiser. Does that mean the ambassador violated diplomatic rules and reached out to the Democrats? Last year, David has written in his blog: Advice for Chancellor Merkel: Reach Out to US Democrats. Our sidebar contains a list of the latest links to articles on transatlantic issues recommended by our readers. If you are interested in contributing to our little web 2.0 project, please read more information here. Ryanair Plans to Offer Transatlantic Flights for 10-12 EurosPosted by Joerg Wolf in Transatlantic Relations on Friday, April 13. 2007
The Times:
Ryanair’s Michael O’Leary promised £7 tickets to the US and Southwest Airlines, the American pioneer of no-frills travel, signalled its intention to start flying to the UK. The prospect of cheap flights from London to New York will revive memories of Freddie Laker’s ultimately doomed challenge to the flag carriers 30 years ago. However, liberalisation of air travel through last month’s “open skies” agreement promises to revolutionise transatlantic travel. Ryanair, Europe’s biggest low-cost carrier, yesterday unveiled plans to offer flights to Baltimore, Rhode Island and New York for as little as 10-12 euros each way, but the service is likely to face stiff competition.Personal comment: If ticket prices indeed drop a lot, that would promote more transatlantic travels, personal exchanges and mutual understanding and might decrease Anti-Americanism and Euro-Bashing. More flights, however, would also be bad news for climate protection efforts. Prescription for Lefties: "Take 2 Antiams, Call Me in Morning"Posted by Joerg Wolf in Transatlantic Relations on Friday, April 6. 2007
Bogdan Kipling's article in the Canadian Chronicle Herald (published March 27, 2007) has a creative headline: "Prescription for political success: take 2 Antiams, call me in morning."
IN COUNTRY after country, anti-Americanism is the magic potion for political weakness. If you’re the president of Upper Slovobia and your popularity is sinking, take a swig from this bottle. You’d be surprised how effective the concoction is. Countless polls, elaborate or basic, confirm that Yankee-bashing works. To name the most obvious example: Five years ago, Gerhard Schroeder, Germany’s chancellor then and Vladimir Putin’s hired hand now, refloated his political wreck of an election pumping this noxious liquefied stench.If Anti-Americanism works like magic "in country after country" why does Mr. Kipling need a five years old example? Dialog International writes about the prescription for righties: "Reach for Munich" "When you've got absolutely nothing, reach for Munich" said blogger Robert Farley, speaking about the propensity of American right-wing ideologues to use the historical analogy of Munich 1938 to punish their adversaries on the left and promote perpetual war as the only solution to geopolitical conflicts. It's always Munich 1938 in the bizarro-world of right-wing America; every perceived enemy is Hitler and every individual who advocates diplomacy over war is a Chamberlain. The Flaws of Some Anti-Anti-AmericanismPosted by Joerg Wolf in Transatlantic Relations on Wednesday, March 14. 2007
Andrew Hammel has reviewed Andrei Markovits' latest book "Uncoth Nation," which identifies "three pitfalls of anti-anti-Americanism:"
1. Defensive denial/Complete identification. The anti-anti-American becomes so fed up with the supercilious tone of European anti-Americanism (or so afraid of "giving the other side ammunition") that he defends U.S. policy even against spot-on critiques.Andrew Hammel's excellent review is at German Joys. The Atlantic Review has written about Markovits' new book in the posts Anti-Americanism and Anti-Semitism and How Widespread is Anti-Americanism? Stay tuned for more comments and reviews of Prof. Markovits' new book in the next few weeks.
« previous page
(Page 3 of 8, totaling 90 entries)
next page »
|
SponsorTips From Our Readers
The above links on transatlantic issues have been recommended by trusted readers. More information about this web 2.0 project ;-)
BlogrollGoogle the SiteSUPPORT THIS SITEHot TopicsClick on one of the following links to see all Atlantic Review posts about this topic in a chronological order with the latest post on top:
Afghanistan Anti-Americanism Economics Iran Iraq Merkel Polls Terrorism Click here for the full list of all topics. Read posts from specific Atlantic Review authors |
Home - About Us - Newsletter - Transatlantic Relations - US Foreign Policy - Various RSS Feeds Designed for Atlantic Review by Carl.

Latest Comments
I want to do a quick drive-by and say thank you Kerneuropaer. You gave me the clue I [...]
Don S about FT: "Speed of European Response Leaves US Trailing"
How.... unilteral of you. What you are saying is that in systems where many [...]
Zyme about FT: "Speed of European Response Leaves US Trailing"
Basically you could say that we are full of trust as long as we are full in control [...]
Don S about FT: "Speed of European Response Leaves US Trailing"
What? You mean they're not going to open that 8-star hotel after all! Such a loss [...]
Don S about Financial Crisis: "Trans-Atlantic Sniping"
SC, I know and love the Ozarks. I've even been to Rolla once or twice when I lived in [...]
Marie Claude about FT: "Speed of European Response Leaves US Trailing"
only t happens that some believe in a godveal