Top Democrat on Auschwitz, Guantanamo and EuropePosted by Joerg Wolf in Transatlantic Relations on Tuesday, October 30. 2007 Dutch lawmakers claim that Rep. Tom Lantos, D-Calif., chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, told them that "Europe was not as outraged by Auschwitz as by Guantanamo Bay." Michael van der Galiën from the Netherlands takes issue with that comparison as well as with Lantos' demand: "You have to help us, because if it was not for us you would now be a province of Nazi Germany." Michael writes in his Van Der Galiën Gazette:
Personal comments: I am surprised that the Democrats have not chosen someone else as chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Committee. Tom Lantos is 79 years old. He has earned and deserves his retirement. (As usual, emphasis in bold added by me.) I did agree with Lantos here: Rep Lantos Calls Ex-Chancellor Schroeder a Political ProstituteAmerica's Cultural SuperiorityPosted by Joerg Wolf in Transatlantic Relations on Saturday, October 13. 2007 More than half of Americans say their culture is superior to others, according to the new Pew Global Attitudes Survey (pdf, p.44):
Question to our readers: Is this feeling of superiority the American equivalent to European Anti-Americanism? While many Europeans make themselves feel good by trashing America and by describing Americans negatively, many Americans -- according to the poll -- make themselves feel good by telling themselves that they are better than others. Personal opinion: Most Americans that I have met are not arrogant and don't act as if they would feel culturally superior. This year's polling results are similar to those from a PEW poll in 2004, which were mentioned in the Atlantic Review post The Superiority of American Culture and Sports, which discussed how several liberal and conservative US media outlets criticize the Soccer World Cup and European culture (nihilism, infantile, defeatist attitudes, etc). Yes, I understand if you mistrust polls. Most polls have some flaws. The critics of Anti-Americanism often point to examples of Anti-American statements to make their case. That method has flaws as well and is not representative or scientific. SuperFrenchie comments on this poll: "Aren't we the ones that are supposed to be arrogant about the superiority of our culture?"UPDATE: On the PEW question re cultural superiority, Central and Eastern Europeans responded like Americans (see statistics on page 97), i.e. the only significant difference is between Americans and Germans, French, Brits and Swedes. Documentary on European Anti-AmericanismPosted by Joerg Wolf in Transatlantic Relations on Friday, October 12. 2007 PBS has broadcast the one-hour documentary "The Anti-Americans (a hate/love relationship)" produced and directed by Louis Alvarez, Andrew Kolker, & Peter Odabashian of the Center for New American Media. Davids Medienkritik calls it a "must-watch documentary" and presents the full length stream. I have commented on a NYT review of this documentary before the videos were online: The Anti-Americans and the Manichaean Narcissists. I have not watched the entire documentary yet, but it seems to be better than the NYT review suggested.Lack of Support for the US, Because "No One Wants to be on the Losing Team"Posted by Joerg Wolf in Transatlantic Relations on Wednesday, October 3. 2007 Anne Applebaum starts her Washington Post column "Why They Don't Like Us" like just another journalist in need of group hug:
But then it gets better: She notes that "there were strong pockets of 'pro-Americanism,' even in the most 'anti-American' countries. In Europe, for example, the upwardly mobile felt more warmly about American power than the establishment." Besides, she blames the US government's "incompetence" for the lack of European willingness to follow US leadership any longer:Continue reading "Lack of Support for the US, Because "No One Wants to be on the Losing Team"" The Anti-Americans and the Manichaean NarcissistsPosted by Joerg Wolf in Transatlantic Relations on Thursday, September 20. 2007 The New York Times starts its review of a documentary about Anti-Americanism with these two sentences: "Do Europeans hate America or love it? Lately the answer might seem a no-brainer." Why is manichaeism so popular in the US media? Why are Europeans not allowed to feel something between love and hate? The US media often gives the impression that many Americans want to be loved and admired by others, and that they are disappointed if foreigners are not so impressed by the land of the free and the home of the brave with the shining city upon a hill. The American people, however, are much more relaxed and not at all narcisstic, I believe. The PBS documentary "The Anti-Americans" presents the usual European characters, if the above mentioned NY Times review is correct: First they show a condescending Brit, then a French woman talking about obese Americans and then those charming Poles, who make country music, wear cowboy hats and wave American flags. It's the usual stereotypes and the typical European dichotomy: The Anti-American Old Europe, and the US loving New Europe. Of course, they don't show one of the many German Western Dance clubs, cowboy fans or country music bands. PBS could have reported that a country band represented Germany at the Eurovision Song Contest, but that does not fit into the prefered characterization of Europeans. Double Standards and the Popularity of 9/11 Conspiracy TheoriesPosted by Joerg Wolf in Transatlantic Relations on Friday, September 14. 2007 Davids Medienkritik is concerned about the popularity of conspiracy theories in Germany, while ignoring their popularity in the US. Ray Drake accuses the German TV station ZDF of "fuelling the conspiracy underworld" because of the results of a totally unscientific poll on the ZDF website: The results (with over 6,000 votes registered) indicate that 65% - or nearly two-thirds - of ZDF participants blame either George W. Bush (26%), US authorities (24%) or the nebulous and ever sinister arms lobby (15%) for 9/11. By comparison, only 27% selected Osama Bin Laden as the culprit and 9% said they didn't know. The blog author and many of his readers make a huge fuss about it in the comment section, but Fuchur has good counter-arguments. Unfortunately, his comment did not stop other blogs from spreading Davids Medienkritik's message. Vodkapundit for instance concludes "German state media: Proud sponsor of 'Truther' nonsense." And Moonbattery has learned from the Medienkritik post that the ZDF documentary "suggests that the American government was actually behind the Muslim atrocities" One American reader informed me about the poll via email and added "With friends like this, who needs Bin-Laden?...." Thank you very much! You are a real friend. Why are these Americans (not all Americans) sooo harsh with Germany? Don't they know that CNN had a similar totally unscientific poll. For some reason America's "Most Trusted Name in News" interviewed the actor Charlie Sheen about 9/11 and then ran an online poll asking "Do you agree with Charlie Sheen that the U.S. government covered up the real events of the 9/11 attacks?" 83% of 54.000 participants answered "Yes." Conspiracy theories are at least as popular in the United States as they are in Germany.
Davids Medienkritik is popular among (neo)conservative Republican supporters. Their main concern is not Anti-Americanism, but rather criticism of conservatives. What they consider Anti-Americanism is often just leftist ideology, which is as popular in Germany as it is in the US. Therefore they do not take into consideration, that leftist conspiracy theories are at least as important in the US as in Germany. Having said that, of course there is a lot of Anti-Americanism in Germany. And Medienkritik sometimes exposes that some German media outlets stereotype Americans as obese or stupid etc. Davids Medienkritik often calls for more diversity of opinions in the German media, but that according to another comment by Fuchur: To give room to these opinions [=conspiracy theories], too. Besides, how is one supposed to deal with these conspiracy theories? I don't think that ignoring them solves the problem; that's just what these people claim: The media won't talk about this, they're hiding the truth, yaddayadda. It's certainly not wrong to address these things - at least once in six years. Is it Anti-Americanism or just Disappointment and Sensitivity?Posted by Editors in German Politics, Transatlantic Relations on Monday, August 6. 2007
Last week, the Atlantic Review reported about US exchange students, who are frustrated to be lectured about the Bush administration's (alleged) wrongdoings by Germans. Our reader Tuomas made an interesting comment, comparing the experience of Americans and foreigners of other nationalities. Besides, he points out that German attitudes can be explained by a certain disappointment with America and by sensitivity towards of nationalism, militarism and supremacism:
Both resident and visiting Americans seem to find "anti-Americanism" in the pure fact that many Germans challenge the superiority of the American political system - and its decisions. I disagree.His comment was slightly shortened. Here is Tuomas' entire comment. Anti-Americanism Does Not MatterPosted by Editors in International Economics, Transatlantic Relations on Friday, August 3. 2007
Joseph Quinlan answers the following questions in The Globalist:
Anti-Americanism has surged during the past five years, largely due to the U.S.-led war in Iraq, even as U.S. foreign affiliates have seen extraordinary profit growth. This begs an obvious question: If the world is so disapproving of the United States, why does it continue to desire and purchase U.S. goods and services? Orangutan's Art in GermanyPosted by Joerg Wolf in German Politics on Tuesday, July 31. 2007
Spiegel International:
An orangutan is holding his first solo exhibition of his paintings in a zoo in Germany. Like many artists, he knows the therapeutic value of art: He took up painting after his partner died.Please, don't accuse Germany of Anti-Americanism, when you learn the name of the orangutan. "Buschi" means "bushy" and refers to his long hair, I guess. Frustrated by Anti-Americanism, US Exchange Students Try to Change German AttitudesPosted by Joerg Wolf in Fulbright, Transatlantic Relations on Saturday, July 28. 2007
"US students are having a hard time in Germany, as they find themselves having to justify Washington policy from day to day. A new pilot project in German schools is meant to help Americans deal with the endless drill" writes Jan Friedmann in Spiegel:
Despite his affinity for German culture, Janssen has hardly been welcomed with open arms. "I don't like having to play diplomat here," he complains. Many of the roughly 3,200 US students enrolled in foreign study programs in Germany share Janssen's experience. They are reluctant ambassadors, routinely taken to task by students and even complete strangers for the perceived offences of their government at home -- an affront that visiting students and academics from China, Russia and Arab countries rarely encounter. Continue reading "Frustrated by Anti-Americanism, US Exchange Students Try to Change German Attitudes" French Pro-AmericanismPosted by Joerg Wolf in Transatlantic Relations on Thursday, July 26. 2007
"Whenever a French person does something anti-American, we hear about it. But when 2500 French do something pro-American..." writes someone on Digg and links to a project on Omaha Beach on July 4, 2007:
The crowd formed on the sand the letters of the phrase: “FRANCE WILL NEVER FORGET”, aimed at honoring the fallen American heroes who scarified their lives to liberate France at the end of WW II.RELATED: David Frum of the National Review noticed that tobacconists in France sell firecrackers. That's why he does not take European "complains" about the American gun lobby seriously. Debatable Land asks whether Frum is joking. I can't answer that question. I am German and don't have a sense of humor. Favorable Views of the U.S. Drop Again in GermanyPosted by Joerg Wolf in Transatlantic Relations on Sunday, July 1. 2007 Pew Global Attitudes Project:Russia and its president also are unpopular in many countries of the world. But criticisms of that nation and its leader are sharpest in Western Europe where many citizens worry about overdependence on the Russian energy supply. For instance, despite sharp declines in favorable views of the U.S. in France and Germany since 2002, Russia's image in those countries is no better. (...)
« previous page
(Page 2 of 8, totaling 89 entries)
next page »
|
SponsorTips From Our Readers
The above links on transatlantic issues have been recommended by trusted readers. More information about this web 2.0 project ;-)
SUPPORT THIS SITEGoogle the SiteBlogroll
Hot TopicsClick on one of the following links to see all Atlantic Review posts about this topic in a chronological order with the latest post on top:
Afghanistan Anti-Americanism Economics Iran Iraq Merkel Polls Terrorism Click here for the full list of all topics. Read posts from specific Atlantic Review authors |
Home - About Us - Newsletter - Transatlantic Relations - US Foreign Policy - Various RSS Feeds Designed for Atlantic Review by Carl.

Latest Comments
France, that they were simply not European enough yet. I agree for Istambul, [...]
Pat Patterson about Karadzic's Arrest: Triumph of European Soft Power?
Turkey is being kept out because of some ongoing problems in Cyprus? That must be [...]
franchie about Karadzic's Arrest: Triumph of European Soft Power?
http://online.wsj.com/public/r esources/documents/pearl123199 .htm This is a vast [...]
Editor, Common Ground News Blog about Karadzic's Arrest: Triumph of European Soft Power?
I don't think that celebrating a victory earned through persistent use of soft power [...]
quo vadis about Karadzic's Arrest: Triumph of European Soft Power?
"Well, obviously, without the wars, they might still be in power." What actually [...]
Kevin Sampson about Karadzic's Arrest: Triumph of European Soft Power?
Now all you have to do is catch Ratko Mladic.
Joe Noory about Germany's Federal Minister of Economics Visited Baghdad
I hate to deflate you Luftballon, but Observing Hermann scooped you by a few days. [...]
Joe Noory about Karadzic's Arrest: Triumph of European Soft Power?
If anything the DELAY of Jerry Garcia arrest was a victory for 'soft power'. His [...]