Posted by Joerg Wolf in
Transatlantic Relations on Saturday, January 14. 2006
Most newspapers believe that Chancellor Merkel's warm welcome in Washington D.C. will not lead to a "new transatlantic romance," but to improved, business-like relations based on more hard-headed practicality and reliability. The U.S.-German realtionship is expected to be less tainted by populist abuse of political disagreements. The chancellor and the president disagreed on Guantanamo, but agreed on a common approach towards Iran. President Bush did not mention the military option, but stressed UN Security Council negotiations. Chancellor Merkel said that as many countries as possible should be persuaded to ally themselves with the US and Germany and not be intimidated by Iran.
On her inaugural visit to Washington D.C. Chancellor Merkel first had breakfast with members of Congress and a 45 minutes one-on-one meeting with President Bush, followed by a joint press conference and lunch. The International Herald Tribune reports:
In what President George W. Bush said was a "spirited" but respectful one-on-one Oval Office session on Friday, the new German chancellor, Angela Merkel, challenged U.S. treatment of terror suspects but lent strong support to joint diplomatic efforts to defuse the nuclear standoff with Iran. Almost formally declaring an end to the tensions that divided the two allies over the Iraq war, Merkel pronounced the opening of a "new chapter" in U.S.-German relations. Bush appeared to agree. Merkel, in her first White House visit since she took office on Nov. 22, said she had raised the question of detainee treatment at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba, with the president. But she appeared to do so in a carefully nonconfrontational way, saying that Europeans critical of such treatment needed to suggest reasonable alternatives for dealing with lawless terrorists. (...) Bush said that Merkel had raised the Guantánamo issue with him, and he again defended it as a necessary way to seek information from terror suspects. (...) The White House appears particularly reassured by her free-market inclinations and the fact that, having grown up in East Germany, she has an inherent skepticism about Russia stronger than that of the former chancellor, Gerhard Schröder.
On Guantanamo, Chancellor Merkel told the press conference: "We openly addressed that there sometimes have been differences of opinion, and I mentioned Guantanamo in this respect." President Bush responded "Guantanamo is a necessary part of protecting the American people and so long as the war on terror goes on... we will inevitably need to hold people that would do ourselves harm." According to the BBC, Ms Merkel said that she had been encouraged by talks with the US president and there was much more to the US-German relationship than their differing opinions on how to respond to the threat of terrorism. She said it was going to be "essential for us not to only talk at governmental level... but our societies need to be engaged". We agree and believe that the Fulbright program, the Atlantic Review and many US and German blogs promote this dialog between our societies.
The NYT praised Chancellor Merkel's statements on Guantanamo:
What infuriated the Bush administration about Mr. Schroeder was that he opportunistically used America-bashing to win votes even as he was cozying up to President Vladimir Putin and trying to lift the European Union's arms embargo against China. Mrs. Merkel has not done that. If she feels strongly about the disgrace of Guantánamo, as all honest people should, she also feels strongly about the importance of trans-Atlantic relations.
COX news service reports about Iran:
President Bush and German Chancellor Angela Merkel on Friday urged the United Nations to take a firm line in dealing with Iranian officials who have defied international concern over Iran's nuclear program. After an Oval Office one-on-one session, Bush and Merkel said their nations are in lockstep concerning Iran, something that was not true about Iraq. "We will certainly not be intimidated by a country such as Iran," said Merkel, on her first White House visit since taking office in November. Bush said, "It's logical that a country which has rejected diplomatic efforts," led by Germany, France and Great Britain, should be referred to the U.N. Security Council for possible sanctions.
The liberal Guardian lets the AP news service opine about a special Bush-Merkel relationship:
Merkel's apparent willingness to work with Bush on trying to stop Iran's nuclear program, as well as in other areas, could be the start of a special closeness. Granted, both Bush and Merkel alluded to their private 45-minute White House meeting Friday as having its "candid'' moments, a diplomatic reference to differences of view. But there was far more harmony evident than discord. (... ) The budding ties between Bush and Merkel may be magnified by the known distaste Merkel's predecessor, Gerhard Schroeder, and Bush had for each other, particularly over the Iraq war. It got to the point that Bush refused to telephone Schroeder with congratulations on winning the chancellorship in 2002 and even would not take a call a week later when Schroeder tried to get in touch.
The White House provides the transcript and video of President Bush's and Chancellor Merkel's press conference.
Many Americans criticize the Merkel government for the alleged ransom payment to Susanne Osthoff's kidnappers and for the recent release of Mohammad Ali Hammadi from a German jail, who killed a Navy officer during Hezbollah hijacking of TWA Flight 847 in 1985.
Deutsche Welle opined about Chancellor Merkel's Guantanamo comments and her recent meeting with Secretary Rice in Berlin:
She is the first European head of government to issue clear demands on specific issues, be it the treatment of prisoners in Guantanamo, the abduction of suspects or the establishing of secret CIA prisons. Specific criticism rather than blanket condemnation is something even George Bush can deal with -- especially since Merkel always combines her remarks with a commitment to German-American friendship.
Die Tagesschau opines that the Bush administration understands the need for partners, and Chancellor Merkel offered support without tendering (What's the polite version of "without sucking up"?):
Washington ist darauf angewiesen, Partner zu finden, die bei der Problemlösung behilflich sind: Vom Iran über den Irak bis nach Afghanistan. Angela Merkel hat sich angeboten, ohne sich anzudienen - das ist klug und im Interesse Deutschlands.
The Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung and Die Zeit have more commentary in German. The latter's beginning is not so promising, but it gets more interesting.
Welcome! You are reading the ATLANTIC REVIEW -- a Press Digest on Transatlantic Relations combined with commentary and analysis by three young professionals from Germany, the Netherlands and the United States. More about us.
The horizontal menu bar at the top helps to navigate this site.
Subscribe to one of our RSS-Feeds or to our newsletter, which is emailed twice per month.
We appreciate any thoughtful comment!
Would you like to read more? Have a look at our directory of Atlantic Review posts.
Or check out the constantly updated reading recommendations from our readers in the sidebar: "Tips From Our Readers." More information on this project in this post. Feel free to comment on any article recommended in the sidebar.
BBCode format allowed. You can make a clickable link with this code: If you write "[url=http://america-germany.atlanticreview.org]Carnival of US-German Relations[/url]", then this will be displayed: "Carnival of US-German Relations". And if you write "[url]http://atlanticreview.org/mustreads.html[/url]", then this will be displayed: "http://atlanticreview.org/mustreads.html"
|
On The Atlantic Review, "Jorg" covers the White House visit by newly-elected Chancellor Angela Merkel. He finds reason for optimism in a piece entitled "A New Chapter in U.S.-German Relations." The chancellor and the president disagreed on Guantanamo, but agreed on a common approach towards Iran. President Bush did not mention the military option, but stressed UN Security Council negotiations. Chancellor Merkel said that as many countries as possible should be persuaded to ally themselves with the US and Germany and not be intimidated by Iran I am inclined to agree with this sentiment, which "Jorg" quotes from Deutsche Welle:
Tracked: Jan 17, 15:41